Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amy's avatar

Great piece! I LOVE birds and one of the joys of my life is watching and listening to birds...but I cannot for the life of me remember most of their names, no matter how many times I write them down in my nature journal, and I've harbored a vague sense of unease over this, as though I'm not a "real" birder. Good food for thought!

Expand full comment
Duncan Cocking's avatar

What a great piece. I'm very much "in between" when it comes to this. As an Permaculture educator I need to know the names of plants to relay to my audience. But as a gardener, I don't feel like they add much value to what I do. For example, I use a lot of weeds as indicators of soil qualitites. Cape Weed (Arctotheca calendula, I had to look that up) is one such plant. I don't need to know the name of the plant, but I do notice a pattern emerge that Cape Weed proliferates on soil that's been disturbed in the last two to three years. After about three years other plants replace them as the ecosystem succession advances. This sort of observation helps me to read the landscape. Knowing the name of the indicator plant is critical to me in assisting others to understand the value in this plant as an indicator. This in turn encourages them to be better observers of nature.

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts